I’ve had to think very long and hard about writing this blog post because I definitely have some conflicting feelings about my T189 results.
The OES (Overall Examinable Component) mark I received for the ECA was 70/100 which was rather disappointing because I was really hoping to get a mark between 75 and 85. From feedback received on OpenStudio and on Flickr, I got the impression that my images were good and some were very good so only to get ‘Achieved’ for the visual and technical marks on my ECA panel was a bit of a let-down
I know I didn’t master some of the more involved techniques in Elements 5 and that seems to have impacted on my Technical Awareness mark but I simply didn’t have the extra hours required to invest in such a complex program on top of the course work and the time for photo assignments. I also use a trackball due to RSI which is hardly an ideal tool for delicate image editing and I didn’t have spare cash to buy a graphics tablet
So here are my marks:
Part 1a – Visual Awareness – Achieved
Your images showed a satisfactory level of visual awareness. Your panel of images had one or two images with good visual impact and showed some evidence of imagination and creativity. Some of your images communicated their intention clearly and made use of ideas taught in the course about framing, lighting, and decisive moments. About half of the images in your panel could be improved upon and the best way to develop your visual awareness is to keep taking pictures and looking at them critically.
Part 1b – Technical Awareness – Achieved
Your panel of images demonstrates a reasonable level of technical skill. Several of your images are appropriately exposed and sharp, and demonstrate your control of the camera. If you have edited your images then your mark may reflect problems with the colour, pixelation, or other digital artefacts. A common problem for beginners to photography is the over-saturation and over-sharpening of images. The technical standard that you have reached is satisfactory and with practice your technical skill will improve. You may find it helpful to review the course and think about how your images could be improved from a technical point of view.
Part 2 – Written Component – Well Achieved
Your answers to the written component of the ECA show a sound understanding of photographic techniques and aesthetic considerations. You have written appropriately about your images and used some of the terms introduced in the course, and demonstrated a developing understanding.
Since my next course is about to start and my course materials will probably be arriving tomorrow, I’m going to put T189 away for now and just continue snapping away with my little compact camera. I’m not even sure if it’s worth investing in a new camera so I may put that idea on the back burner for a while. I did enjoy T189 and I did enjoy taking photographs for the assignments and ECA, I did get a pass after all and it’s not a bad one, but somehow I feel rather flat and disillusioned today … sorry, but that is honestly how I feel right now. Maybe I’ll feel better tomorrow – it is my birthday after all
Goodnight folks.
I am so sorry that you are feeling down about your mark. 70 is a good mark, equivalent to a 2:1 degree classification and still a great achievement. I have taken a look at your photo-stream and your work is lovely. There are some small elements on the images which you had marked as for the ECA, which could possibly be improved. Things such as a the detail being a little ’soft’ on the amarylis, a little overexposure of the wall in the bird picture or a leaf in the corner of the frame in the pear picture. This does not mean these are bad pictures, far from it, but they could be even better. Please don’t give up on your photography, the only way to improve really is to keep practicing. All good photographers are constantly looking to improve…and don’t give up on the idea of a DSLR, you will enjoy the new opportunities and control it gives you.
Comment by Georgy — September 13, 2007 @ 12:29 pm |
Happy Birthday! This: “I did enjoy T189 and I did enjoy taking photographs for the assignments and ECA”; is 90% of the battle right there. Don’t sweat rankings, they are objective. Unless you plan on doing this for a living the important question is this: “Do I get joy from taking and processing images?” If the answer is yes, you are way ahead.
R.
Comment by Jersey Guy — September 13, 2007 @ 3:54 pm |
Sorry to hear that you are feeling a bit down, your photos were really good! Anyway happy birthday, hope you have a great day.
Comment by Wanda — September 14, 2007 @ 1:19 pm |
Happy Birthday Aqua!!, but sorry to read you’re feeling a bit disappointed with your results. Having looked through the links on the flickr group, the results really do cover the full spectrum, and in some cases, i find it difficult to work out why some may have got 90+ and others got in the lower 70s – they *all* look excellent to me.
As Jersey Guy said above, the important thing is what *you* gained from the course – did you enjoy it? yes. Did you feel it helped you to improve your photography? Yes. ….then the course was a success for you
Apart from anything else, reading your posts has inspired me to take the course. If my ECA panel in December comes out looking half as good as yours, I shall be thrilled
k
Comment by Kvj — September 14, 2007 @ 2:45 pm |
Thanks for your comments everyone
You are so right – I am ahead!
Georgy, thanks for your reassurance, I’ve not had much time to spend on my photography since I finished T189 and my next course is about to start (14/16+ hours per week – *eek*) I don’t harbour any aspirations to a DSLR – it would be totally wasted on me and I simply don’t have that kind of money to spend on a camera.
Jersey Guy, thanks for the birthday wishes – I had a lovely day
Thanks Wanda, I’m not feeling quite so down today.
Kvj, I’m really happy to learn that my blog inspired you to take the course. I looked at your Flickr photostream and the images there are excellent – you’ll really enjoy T189. I’m sure you’ll do very well!
Comment by aquamarina — September 14, 2007 @ 9:30 pm |
Just a small correction to my earlier post. “Don’t sweat rankings, they are objective” should have read, “Don’t sweat rankings, they are not objective”
R.
Comment by Jersey Guy — September 17, 2007 @ 7:12 am |
HI Aquamarina,
dont feel too low, I think your photos are great and you have done really well.
if it was not for you and a few others I would not have booked to do the October course and I am really looking forward to it and I hope you will continue to take photos and write your blog.
take care
Pete
Comment by hartrockets — September 17, 2007 @ 6:44 pm |
Thanks Pete – much appreciated.
I’m feeling much better now and even planning to buy a new camera … but which one????
Comment by aquamarina — September 17, 2007 @ 9:51 pm |